Are Black Diamonds Worthless? The Truth From 30 Years of Expert Experience
For decades, black diamonds have been misunderstood. Many people assume they are "worthless" compared to white diamonds or other gemstones—but that's a myth True Sanity founder Amit Jhalani has spent his career debunking.
Since 1996, Amit has sold loose black diamonds and set jewelry, and in 1997 he purchased his first natural, untreated black diamond—GIA-certified—a moment that ignited his lifelong passion for these mysterious gems.
Here, drawing on Amit's three decades of experience, insider knowledge, and real-world case studies, we reveal the truth about black diamond value.
Black Diamonds Have Real Value—Both Natural and Treated
Contrary to common misconceptions, black diamonds are far from worthless. In fact, prices for both natural and treated black diamonds have risen steadily, driven by:
- Rising demand in engagement rings, fashion, and collector markets
- Limited availability of high-quality stones
- Global trade factors, including tariffs and import costs
Natural black diamonds have seen the most dramatic increase in value, climbing 5x to 10x over the last two decades.
"Natural black diamonds are probably more rare than white diamonds in terms of high-quality stones. You can find plenty of black diamonds in the rough—but finding clean ones, without pits, clouds, or surface flaws, is exceptionally rare."
— Amit Jhalani, True Sanity FounderThe Difference Between Natural and Treated Black Diamonds
Natural black diamonds are unique gems formed deep within the Earth, often with mineral inclusions that give them their signature black color. Their rarity is not just in existence but in quality: clean, well-formed, and beautifully faceted natural black diamonds are extremely rare and therefore valuable.
Treated black diamonds are also genuine diamonds, but their color has been enhanced through human processes. While treated diamonds are generally more available, high-quality stones are becoming increasingly rare, particularly in years when new finds (like Salt and Pepper diamonds) flood the market and soften pricing temporarily.
"Even treated black diamonds are gaining in value. You can't grow them in a lab, and nice-quality stones will only become more limited over time."
— Amit JhalaniWhether you're looking for black diamond rings or other pieces, understanding this distinction matters.
Why Many People Think Black Diamonds Are "Worthless"
Several misconceptions fuel the myth:
Common Misconceptions:
Resale challenges – Out of ~27,000 jewelry retailers in the U.S., only 1% truly understand black diamonds, making resale difficult.
Diamond tester confusion – Many buyers of treated black diamonds are told their stone is "fake" because conventional testers fail to account for treatment. Only GIA-quality testing equipment can accurately evaluate them.
Visual imperfections – Black diamonds often have pits, clouds, or uneven surfaces, which some buyers mistake for flaws rather than natural characteristics.
"Black diamonds aren't worthless. They're misunderstood. Their real value comes from proper cutting, certification, and an informed buyer."
— Amit JhalaniEvaluating a Black Diamond: What Truly Matters
Unlike white diamonds, evaluating a black diamond is a nuanced process. Key factors include:
Surface quality – Are there pits or scratches on the table or pavilion?
Depth and symmetry – Is the cut proportional and visually appealing? Many black diamonds are poorly cut, but True Sanity ensures beautifully faceted stones.
Color consistency – For treated stones, how even is the blackness?
Certification – Only a GIA report guarantees authenticity and treatment status.
"GIA certification is critical. A black diamond over 1 carat from True Sanity always comes with a GIA certificate. It's the only way to assign real value."
— Amit JhalaniThis standard applies across our entire collection, from black diamond earrings to black diamond necklaces.
Case Study: Teaching the Market About Value
A memorable example of Amit's expertise involves a collector who initially purchased a treated black diamond. Curious about natural stones, the collector asked Amit if he could source one.
After extensive research in Surat, India, Amit acquired a natural, untreated black diamond and sent it to GIA for verification. It passed as authentic, marking the start of Amit's lifelong journey in black diamonds.
"That experience wasn't just about business. It taught me the importance of transparency, proper certification, and educating buyers about real value."
Transparency and True Value
At True Sanity, transparency is as essential as rarity. While many jewelry companies hide details about treatment, pricing, or sourcing, True Sanity ensures customers understand exactly what they are buying.
Amit believes: "A black diamond's beauty isn't just in its color—it's in its story, its authenticity, and the honesty behind the transaction."
This philosophy ensures that buyers not only receive a genuine, certified diamond but also an education about why it is valuable—financially, aesthetically, and emotionally.
From elegant black diamond studs to statement black diamond bracelets, every piece tells a story of authenticity.
Myth-Busting Summary: Black Diamonds Are NOT Worthless
- Both natural and treated black diamonds are real diamonds
- Natural black diamonds are extremely rare, especially in high-quality, clean stones
- Treated black diamonds retain real value, though their resale requires knowledge and certification
- Prices have increased significantly, with natural black diamonds rising 5–10x over the past decades
- Resale is tricky, but knowledgeable buyers and certified stones hold value
- GIA certification is essential for verifying authenticity and assigning value
- Appearance alone doesn't determine worth—quality of cut and surface integrity matter
- Even experts can't tell natural vs. treated by eye alone, underscoring the importance of certification
- Black diamonds are often misrepresented as worthless due to ignorance, not reality
- Transparency is the core of value, both in business and in gemstone transactions
Final Thought: The True Worth of Black Diamonds
The real value of black diamonds lies not just in rarity or price, but in knowledge, transparency, and quality. Amit Jhalani's three decades of experience, from sourcing natural stones in Surat to selling treated gems worldwide, prove a simple truth:
Black diamonds are far from worthless—they are misunderstood, undervalued, and waiting for informed buyers to recognize their true worth.
For collectors, couples, and jewelry enthusiasts, a GIA-certified black diamond from True Sanity isn't just a gemstone—it's a piece of history, science, and beauty, with a story as deep and mysterious as the stone itself.
Explore Certified Black Diamond Jewelry
Discover ethically sourced, GIA-certified black diamonds with complete transparency and expert guidance.